November 15, 2007, California Healthline
Assembly Panel OKs Democrats' Health Care Overhaul
Proposal
On Wednesday, the Assembly Health Committee approved a revised health care
reform proposal (ABX1 1) by Democratic legislative leaders, setting the stage for
a final vote on an overhaul plan this month, the Sacramento
Bee reports. The plan received no votes from Republican committee
members (Yamamura, Sacramento Bee, 11/15).
Prospects of a Compromise
Assembly Speaker Fabian Núñez (D-Los Angeles) and Senate President Pro
Tempore Don Perata (D-Oakland) unveiled the plan last week. The plan more
closely resembles Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's (R) health care plan than an
earlier Democratic proposal did, but differences remain over employer
contributions and how to finance the proposed coverage expansion.
The
Democrats favor a tobacco tax increase of $2 per pack, while the governor has
proposed leasing the state lottery to a private operator.
The funding
mechanism would be packaged as a ballot initiative that would go before voters
in the November 2008 election (California Healthline,
11/14).
Jennifer Kent, associate secretary of legislative affairs for the
Department of Health Care Services, said Schwarzenegger also remains concerned
over the Democrats' provision to exempt some residents from the individual
coverage mandate.
Next Step
On Nov. 26, the full Assembly will vote on the Democrats' health care reform
plan.
Núñez said, "We're making considerable progress, and I expect
we're going to get a deal." He added that setting a voting date before a
compromise has been reached shows "how strongly we feel we're going to get it
done."
Opposition
Opponents of the Democrats' plan at Wednesday's hearing included the
California Nurses Association and the California Restaurant Association. The
restaurant group argued that employer contributions would hurt businesses with a
large amount of workers but small profit margins.
Also concerned that
the plan would hurt businesses, Republican committee members questioned whether
the revenue sources of the plan could cover rising health care costs.
The committee rejected Assembly Republicans' reform proposal (ABX1 8). It would have provided tax incentives for purchasing
health insurance and an option to obtain out-of-state coverage (Sacramento
Bee, 11/15).
Budget Deficit
Meanwhile, rising concerns about California's projected budget deficit is
putting pressure on Schwarzenegger and Democrats to consider spending cuts and
tax increases in the midst of trying to pass a comprehensive health care reform
bill, the San Jose Mercury News reports.
In a report released Wednesday, the Legislative Analyst's Office
estimated that California's budget deficit will reach almost $10 billion over
the next two years (Harmon/Sheppard, San Jose Mercury News, 11/15).
The governor contends that overhauling California's health care system
would provide a boost to the economy, but critics of the governor's health plan
argue that the proposal could exacerbate the budget deficit (Mendel, San Diego Union-Tribune, 11/15).
Meeting on Schwarzenegger's Health Care Plan
On Wednesday, the African American Health Institute of San Bernardino County
held a meeting to discuss Schwarzenegger's health care plan, the San Bernardino
County Sun reports.
Kathleen Webb, director of the Office of
the Insurance Adviser, took note of recommendations from black health experts
and professionals at the meeting.
Suggestions included more culturally
sensitive health care providers and a separate revenue source for addressing
health issues in the black community.
Webb said some of the
recommendations will be worked into the governor's proposal (Sorba, San
Bernardino County Sun, 11/14).
Opinion Pieces
Summaries of opinion pieces regarding the health care reform debate in
California appear below.
- George Skelton, Los Angeles Times: "If I were advising the
governor ... I'd tell him to pull the plug on health care reform" and
"announce that he has given it his best effort for the past year," Skelton
writes in his "Capitol Journal" column for the Times.
Schwarzenegger now must "focus on a genuine crisis of pending bankruptcy,"
according to Skelton. "Nothing really can be done to improve the lives of
Californians until state government becomes fiscally sound," Skelton writes
(Skelton, Los Angeles Times, 11/15).
- Michael Russo, San Diego Union-Tribune: "A tobacco tax is the
right way to break the negotiating stalemate and fully fund the comprehensive
health care reform that California needs," Russo, a health care advocate and
attorney at CALPIRG, writes in a Union-Tribune opinion piece.
"It's true that over time, reducing smoking will also decrease the revenue
brought in by the tax. But those budget losses will be balanced by savings,
because nonsmokers tend to be healthier and spend less money on medical care
than smokers," according to Russo (Russo, San Diego
Union-Tribune, 11/15).
Broadcast Coverage
Capital Public Radio's "KXJZ News" on Thursday reported on the committee vote. The
segment includes comments from Núñez (O'Mara, "KXJZ News," Capital Public Radio,
11/15).
A transcript and audio of the segment are available
online.